Skip to Content

Review: Diary of a Mad Fat Girl

There are about 10 billion things I need to do before the weekend begins for me. (You too?) Among them, share a review of Diary of a Mad Fat Girl by Stephanie McAfee. This is the latest selection of the BlogHer Book Club and it comes with an interesting back story: Stephanie McAfee originally self-published this book and it sprang to popularity, garnering her a literary agent and a traditional publisher in the process. It’s one of those awesome modern stories of self-publishing and traditional publishing colliding.

This story is set in the town of Bugtussle, Mississippi, where Gracelia “Ace” Jones is an outspoken high school art teacher who lives in the home she grew up in with her grandmother. When her two best friends find themselves in trouble — one accused of sleeping with a student and the other a victim of an abusive husband — Ace naturally steps up and helps them both. There are some themes of love and espionage too …

This is a light reading book. Really light. It’s a what-you-see-is-what-you-get kind of story. The characters aren’t well-developed. Their backstories, when presented, don’t seem to influence them. And things like heartbreak and weight issues are occasional themes, not constant ones. And the dialogue. Oh, the dialogue. Sometimes, it felt more like what someone might imagine saying rather than what they really did.

Still, and this is especially hard to believe for me, I found myself looking forward to digging into a few more pages every time I glimpsed the cover. And though the story was predictable with foreshadowing practically encased in neon lights, I looked forward to seeing what happened in the end. I’d be lying if I said I connected with the characters. I didn’t. And the prose in this book were just okay … it has nothing on any great works of literature. Still … This wasn’t a me book, but I still enjoyed it. It was a fluffy, fun read.

I guess what I am saying is that sometimes an ultra-light book can capture my interest and make me smile a bit. That’s not a bad thing. Just don’t look for any deep themes or a solid connection with this book.

Be sure to hop over to the BlogHer Book Club page for Diary of a Mad Fat Girl to read more about this book and join the discussion.

Disclosure: This review was created as part of the BlogHer Book Club program. I was provided with a copy of the book and am compensated for my participation. However, all opinions are my own.

Do You Talk Around the Dinner Table?
Toss Together Chorizo, Feta and Tomato Pasta


Saturday 10th of March 2012

I don't know if you know this, but I love your book reviews. I never know what's out there that's worth adding to my giant stack of "to be reads"


Saturday 10th of March 2012

Kate, I love doing them. I think I might include some more that aren't part of the book club. I am so glad you love them. It's great to hear.


Friday 9th of March 2012

Sometimes you need a nice light book to enjoy... and to look forward to. It's too bad the characters weren't well developed, maybe she'll write another book and grow as an author.


Saturday 10th of March 2012

For sure, Patsy. This book was quirky in that I really wanted to read more even though the things I usually look for in a book weren't present.