Skip to Content

Deep Dish Pizza Dough

 

Homemade Deep Dish Pizza

I was having a craving for deep dish pizza last week and decided to try making it at home. I’ve made thin crust pizza dough a few times before by hand, but have never made deep dish or used my Breadman to create the dough. I decided to do both this time. Using the Breadman made the process so much easier.

This dough works well in a deep dish pizza stone or pan. It’s also cook in a countertop pizza oven, if you own one. We used to — but when it died we didn’t replace it.

If you decide to do this, then be sure to allow enough time to make the dough and let it rise twice. The kneading and first rising in the Breadman took about 1 1/2 hours. The second rising was another 30 minutes. Plus it takes 20-30 minutes to cook. Obviously, this isn’t a quick dinner.

Anyway, I like the taste of homemade dough better than the stuff you can pick up in your local supermarket deli or bakery. But then, I like most things I create myself at home. It’s just a me thing.

With a deep dish pizza, according to The Best Pizza Is Made at Home (A Nitty Gritty Cookbook) by Donna Rathmell German “Layer ingredients in this order: cheese, meats, sauce, vegetables and seasonings. Leave a 1/2-inch border around the rim of the pizza.”

This recipe comes from that reliable but out of print cookbook. Fortunately you can still snag used copies on Amazon.

Deep Dish Pizza Dough

Deep Dish Pizza Dough

Yield: 1 pizza crust

Ingredients

  • 1 cup lukewarm water
  • 1/4 cup olive oil
  • 3 cups bread flour
  • 1/2 tsp salt
  • 1 tsp sugar
  • 1 1/2 tsp active dry yeast

Instructions

  1. Layer ingredients in the pan of a bread maker in the order listed. Set bread maker to dough cycle and start. If your bread machine has two rising cycles, remove the dough after the first.When dough is complete with kneading and first rising, remove from the breadmaker and stretch or roll it into a circle. Place it in a greased deep dish pan, allowing it to creep up the sides a bit. Cover and let rise for 30 minutes.
  2. If you are using a pizza stone and oven, then preheat oven to 475 degrees. While the dough is rising, grate or slice your cheese, prepare meats and veggies into appropriate sizes and gather other toppings (herbs, sauce, etc). DO this because once the dough is done, you have to act quickly.
  3. Remove cover from dough and prick the surface with a fork (roughly every 1/2 inch). Cook the dough for five minutes in the preheated oven or unheated pizza oven.
  4. Remove the dough from the oven or open the pizza oven and brush with olive oil all over. Layer toppings, leaving the aforementioned border.
  5. Place pizza in the oven or close lid and cook 20-30 minutes, until crust is golden. In my pizza oven, it was ready in about 21 minutes (though I let it go longer by mistake).

 

Suggested toppings:

– hot Italian sausage
– fresh basil
– tomatoes
– chicken
– artichoke hearts
– spinach
– ground beef
– broccoli
– clams

Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links

Previous
A Look Inside My Fridge
Next
Zuppa Toscana Recipe | Soup with Sausage, Kale, Bacon and Potatoes

Thin Crust Pizza Dough Recipe - Sarah's Cucina Bella

Monday 5th of January 2015

[…] now 9-years-old and is still a pizza fanatic. From deep dish pizza to breakfast pizza and everything in between, Will loves it all. And it wasn’t a big surprise […]

Homemade Pizza Recipe: Chicken Basil Pizza - Sarah's Cucina Bella

Sunday 4th of January 2015

[…] pizza crust from scratch. I have two go-to recipes –one for a perfect thin crust and a flaky┬ádeep dish pizza crust. But this time, I went for speed, using a premade dough from my local grocery store. It’s a […]

Secrets of a Good Homemade Pizza - Sarah's Cucina Bella

Sunday 4th of January 2015

[…] I’d use store-bought dough. Other times I would make my own — using my recipe for deep dish pizza dough or a different one for a thinner […]

Sarah Caron

Saturday 1st of December 2007

Thanks Sarah W.!!! That is great to hear. This is still my go-to recipe for deep dish too. I have tried others, but this is the best by far. I am so glad that it's working well for you too.

Sarah W.

Saturday 1st of December 2007

I've used your pizza dough recipe many times now and every time it comes out amazing! Thanks for the fantastic recipe!!!